Engineering

Screw-Propelled Vehicles: How They Work and Where They Fail

By AAAV Published · Updated

A screw-propelled vehicle rides on two long, buoyant cylinders wrapped in helical blades and turning in opposite directions. The blades bite into soft material, mud, snow, floating vegetation or water, and push the vehicle along the axis of the cylinders. The design works best where the surface is soft enough to be gripped but too soft to carry a wheel, and it works worst on firm, dry ground. The US Army Engineer Waterways Experiment Station’s 1977 report on the Chrysler Marsh Screw Amphibian sums up its 1960s test results as about 3.2 km/h on dry soils and sand, against 12.2 to 15.8 km/h on open water (WES report).

The idea is older than the motor car. A screw-driven steamboat is credited to Colonel John Stevens in 1804, Jacob Morath patented a screw-propelled farm machine in 1899, three Fordson tractors on screw drums were shipped to Alaska in 1926 to haul expedition freight, Chrysler built the Marsh Screw Amphibian for the US Navy in the 1960s, and the Soviet Union built the ZIL-2906 to reach landed cosmonauts. The same pattern runs through all of them: strong in marsh, mud and some kinds of snow, and slow on firm ground.

How a screw drive works

Each cylinder carries one or more helical flanges, left-handed on one side and right-handed on the other. Turned in opposite directions, the two cylinders push against the ground in a way that cancels the sideways components and leaves forward thrust. Jacob Morath’s 1899 patent states the principle in its own words: the screws are driven in opposite directions, their helices are inclined in reverse on the two shafts, and they “plow” their way through the soil to propel the machine (US 635,501).

The Marsh Screw Amphibian’s figures show how the geometry converts rotation to travel. Its helix has a lead of 48 inches, so with no slip the vehicle advances 4 feet for each revolution of the rotors. At 33 rpm that is 1.5 mph and at 220 rpm it is 10 mph, as the WES report states. Any slip in mud or water means the real speed is lower than this ideal, which is why the same machine is faster over rooted vegetation, where the helix has something to push against, than in open water.

The twin-rotor layout behaves like this:

  • Straight travel: the cylinders counter-rotate at equal speed.
  • Turning: one cylinder slows or brakes. The Marsh Screw reduced clutch torque to the rotor on the inside of the turn and applied its brake.
  • Sideways travel: both cylinders turn the same way and the vehicle rolls laterally. The WES report notes the Marsh Screw had no provision for steering while moving sideways. Chrysler’s 1968 patent (Zimmerman, US 3,395,671) steers by a hydraulically biased speed difference between the two pontoons, and says that with the propulsion drive locked and both pontoons turning the same way the vehicle can move sideways on firm ground.
  • Dual use of the drum: the cylinder is also the float. The Marsh Screw’s rotors were filled with polyurethane foam to keep water out if the thin metal skin was punctured.

Mud, snow, ice, water and hard ground

The behaviour depends almost entirely on the surface, and the primary sources describe each case.

Mud and marsh. This is the home environment. The WES report ranks the screw machines first overall in wet marshland and recorded the Marsh Screw crossing a 21.5 m canal at 6.2 km/h, and moving through vegetated test lanes, mostly water hyacinth, at 1.6 to 9.8 km/h depending on the density and type of vegetation. Rooted vegetation helped: the observers noted a speed increase over lubricated, rooted vegetation compared with open water. The report’s performance summary, drawn from the 1960s test programs, lists 32.2 km/h on wet, soft clay.

Snow and ice. Frederick Burch’s patent for the Armstead Snow Motor distinguishes the jobs of the drum. On hard snow or ice the drum’s peripheral surface is the main support, in soft snow the ribs supply the driving impulse, and a smooth forward section presses loose snow into a channel in which the ribs can run (US 1,431,440). Chrysler’s later Riverine Utility Craft is listed at 33.3 km/h on snow. Russian accounts rate the Soviet ZIL-29061 cosmonaut-recovery machine at about 25 km/h, with four hours of running, roughly 100 km over snow.

Open water. Screws float and swim, but not fast. The Marsh Screw logged 15.8 km/h with only a driver and 12.2 km/h with its payload. The WES observers noted steering was difficult in free water, “attributed to the lack of firm material in which the helix of the rotor could gain thrust”. For crossing water quickly, a waterjet or a hovercraft is a better answer; the screw’s advantage is that it keeps going when the water turns to mud, weed or ice.

Hard ground. The drive depends on blades displacing a medium. On firm soil it can only drag. The WES report calls the Marsh Screw “grossly underpowered” on deep, sticky clays and on firm soils with no surface water to lubricate the rotors, and gives about 3.2 km/h on dry soils and sand. The larger Riverine Utility Craft is listed at only 5.5 km/h on a hard surface, in side mode. The report concludes that moving screw vehicles any distance over hard surfaces “will have to be by means other than their propulsion systems”, and describes boat trailers and low-bed trailers built to carry them.

SurfaceWhat the screw doesDocumented example
Wet mud, marsh, floating vegetationBlades grip roots and mat; best performanceMarsh Screw 1.6 to 9.8 km/h in vegetated lanes (WES, 1975); 32.2 km/h on wet, soft clay (1960s tests)
Snow and iceRibs drive in soft snow; the drum surface carries the load on hard snow and ice (Burch patent, filed 1920)RUC 33.3 km/h on snow; Fordson Snow Motors slow in Alaska’s cold, dry snow (1926)
Open waterFloats and swims, slowlyMarsh Screw 12.2 to 15.8 km/h; RUC 27.7 km/h
Dry sand, firm soilLittle to push against; dragsMarsh Screw about 3.2 km/h; RUC 5.5 km/h in side mode

Early screw machines and patents, 1804 to 1922

The WES report credits the first practical application of the Archimedean screw to propulsion to Colonel John Stevens, who in 1804 built and operated a screw-driven steamboat on New York’s North River. Land vehicles came later.

  • 1899, Jacob Morath. US 635,501, “Agricultural machine”, filed May 18, 1899 and granted October 24, 1899, uses two propelling shafts carrying four tapered augers, each a continuous spiral blade, with notched cutting edges to sever plant roots. The screws can be raised out of the ground so the machine can run on traction wheels between fields or on roads, an early statement of the hard-ground problem.
  • 1913, Otis Hollis. US 1,069,875, “Tractor”, filed January 9, 1913 and granted August 12, 1913, describes a driving drum whose helical flanges “directly engage in the earth”, paired with a guiding drum with longitudinal flanges.
  • 1920 to 1922, Frederick Burch. US 1,431,440, “Snow motor vehicle”, was filed November 27, 1920 and granted October 10, 1922, with Armstead Snow Motors, Inc. as assignee. It specifies large conoid drums with a smooth forward section and shallow, steeply pitched ribs on the rear, so that several ribs stay in contact with the snow while friction stays moderate.

The Armstead and Fordson Snow Motor of the 1920s

The Fountainhead Antique Auto Museum describes a 1926 Fordson Snow Motor on loan from the Pioneer Air Museum: a Fordson tractor carried on two revolving cylinders with mirror-image spiral ribs, each cylinder driven through its own clutch, with the clutches engaged according to the position of the steering wheel (museum record, 2011). For summer the cylinders and yokes could be removed and the tractor’s own axles and wheels refitted. The museum says Armstead Snow Motors, Inc. of New York sold the apparatus as a conversion kit for several vehicles, including cars, based on the Burch patent.

TIME reported on January 4, 1926 that leading Detroit automobile makers had organised Snow Motors Inc. to build a machine, a Ford tractor power plant on two revolving cylinders, that would cross the deepest snowdrifts at six to eight miles an hour. One machine had done work that formerly required three teams, a stage line in Oregon used one on its two daily round trips over the McKenzie Pass between Eugene and Bend, and orders had come from Canada, Norway, Sweden and Alaska (TIME, January 4, 1926).

The expedition record is less flattering. Three Fordson Snow Motors went to Alaska for Hubert Wilkins and Ben Eielson’s 1926 transpolar flight attempt, to haul ten freight sleds carrying 15 tons of aviation fuel, oil, radio equipment and fuel for the tractors. The museum’s account says the cylinders did not work well in interior Alaska’s cold, dry snow, and the machines were slow and used a great deal of fuel. A machine sold on its ability to cross the deepest drifts performed badly in a different kind of snow, a dependence on surface conditions that runs through every later program.

Chrysler’s Marsh Screw Amphibian and Riverine Utility Craft

Two Marsh Screw Amphibian (MSA) prototypes were designed and built by Chrysler Corporation Defense Engineering in the 1960s for the Department of the Navy, and both ended up at the Waterways Experiment Station in Vicksburg, Mississippi. The WES lists its test history: a Chrysler test report dated July 1963, a WES trafficability report on coarse-grained and fine-grained soils (Technical Report 3-641, January 1964), and a military-potential test by the Army General Equipment Test Activity (final report December 1964). The 1977 WES report summarises these, and it adds its own field demonstration in southern Louisiana in June 1975 for herbicide application against aquatic plants.

The documented specifications of the MSA as tested: empty weight 2,860 lb including driver and fuel, 1,094 lb payload, a ground pressure of 0.52 psi empty and 0.72 psi loaded (at 3 inches of penetration), a Chrysler 225 cubic inch slant-six rated 116 hp at 3,600 rpm, aluminium body and rotors, and a drive through a torque converter and final chain drive to the rotors.

The 1977 verdict was split. The observers agreed that further investigation of screw-propelled vehicles was warranted, and that further evaluation of the MSA in its present configuration was probably not. They listed inadequate power to the rotors, too little payload space, slow water speed, debris building up between the rotors, poor steering off water and vegetation, and a nose-down angle on dense vegetation.

The Riverine Utility Craft (RUC) answered several of these points. The WES appendix, drawn from Chrysler’s July 1970 final report, lists a crew of two, a payload of five passengers or 2,000 lb of cargo, a gross weight of 13,085 lb in cargo configuration, two water-cooled Chrysler engines of 440 cubic inches listed at 380 hp gross at 4,500 rpm, and speeds of 27.7 km/h on water, 32.4 km/h over swamp and tidal flats, 33.3 km/h on snow and 5.5 km/h on a hard surface in side mode. The report notes its rotors and helix angles were optimised for water speed and that the twin engines gave adequate power in firm, dry soils and sticky clays, the MSA’s weak points. Even so, its hard-surface figure stayed at 5.5 km/h.

The Amphirol and a Soviet recovery vehicle

The WES appendix also covers the AMFIROL, built by a Dutch firm at Hulst: 5.6 m long, 3.0 m wide, 3,500 kg empty and 6,000 kg loaded in water, with maker’s speeds of 8 to 10 km/h in open water, 8 to 12 km/h on mud and snow and 20 to 30 km/h on hard or dry ground. The appendix does not say how the hard-ground speed was reached. The Drive credits the Amphirol design to the Dutchman Joseph Jean De Bakker, and his patent (US 3,333,563, filed January 25, 1966, granted August 1, 1967) shows how a screw machine can claim such a figure: its torpedo-shaped pontoons carry ribs of opposite hand and turn in opposite directions for water, while on hard ground both turn the same way and the vehicle moves sideways “as on rollers”.

The Soviet ZIL-2906 was built to reach cosmonauts who came down where wheels could not follow. It came from the ZIL works’ special design bureau (SKB), led by Vitaly Grachev, as the light, screw-driven member of the three-vehicle PEK-490 “Blue Bird” search-and-rescue complex. A six-wheeled ZIL-4906 truck carried it and unloaded it with a hydraulic lifting device when the wheeled vehicles could go no further. The complex appeared in pre-production form in 1975 and entered service in 1981 with the USSR’s unified state aviation search-and-rescue service (Auto Mail.ru, 2018, in Russian). Kolesa.ru describes the modernised ZIL-29061: aluminium screw rotors turned by a pair of VAZ car engines, a fibreglass cab and sides, a speed of about 25 km/h and four hours of running, roughly 100 km over snow. It puts production at five screw vehicles, alongside 12 crane trucks and 14 passenger vehicles, before the Soviet Union broke up (Kolesa.ru, 2014, in Russian). English-language articles quote different figures, such as 45 km/h on snow and about 20 built (Autoevolution), without naming a source. The Drive’s 2017 report on another Soviet screw machine, the restored ZVM-2901, gives it a 159 hp engine and says the ZIL-2906 was meant for remote, swampy areas of Siberia (The Drive).

Modern prototypes

  • Snowbird 6 (2002). The Ice Challenger expedition, which set out to be the first to drive across the ice from Alaska to Siberia, built Snowbird 6 from a vehicle designed for ski resorts, with two counter-rotating screws to drive it across ground and ice. It was trialled on the Thames in London on January 15, 2002, where it sprang a leak and nearly sank, according to Athropolis.
  • Grain Weevil (2021). A 30 lb remote-controlled robot that uses augers to level grain in storage bins so people do not need to enter them. It can dig itself out of up to 5 feet of grain. Its inventors, Nebraska engineering students, won a Lemelson-MIT Student Prize reported by the University of Nebraska-Lincoln on April 28, 2021.

Grain behaves like a soft, deep, flowing medium, so the screw suits it for the same reason it suits mud. Larger screw machines have found industrial work too: The Drive reported in 2017 that the Amphirol design had been adapted and was still in use in the mining industry. For amphibious roles needing speed and range on mixed terrain, the tracked amphibians and the wider field of amphibious vehicle drive systems cover most of the ground.

Dated table of notable machines

YearMachine or patentKey documented figuresSource type
1899Morath agricultural machine, US 635,501Granted October 24, 1899; tapered screws, raisable for road travelPatent
1913Hollis tractor, US 1,069,875Granted August 12, 1913; helical driving drum plus guiding drumPatent
1920 to 1922Burch snow motor, US 1,431,440Filed 27 Nov 1920, granted 10 Oct 1922; smooth front, ribbed rearPatent
1926Fordson Snow Motor (Armstead)TIME: six to eight mph in deep drifts; three taken to Alaska; ten sleds and 15 tons planned; poor in cold, dry snowPress; museum record
1963 to 1964Chrysler Marsh Screw Amphibian2,860 lb empty; 1,094 lb payload; 116 hp; 12.2 to 15.8 km/h water; about 3.2 km/h dry soilsUS Army report
1966 to 1967De Bakker amphibian, US 3,333,563Filed 25 Jan 1966, granted 1 Aug 1967; pontoons turn together or opposedPatent
1970Chrysler Riverine Utility Craft13,085 lb gross (cargo); two 440 cu in engines; 27.7 km/h water; 5.5 km/h hard surfaceUS Army report
1975 to 1991ZIL-2906 and ZIL-29061Carried by a ZIL-4906 truck; about 25 km/h; five screw vehicles builtRussian motoring press
2002Snowbird 6Two counter-rotating screws; trialled January 15, 2002Press
2021Grain Weevil30 lb; digs out of 5 ft of grainUniversity release

The last column matters as much as the figures. Patent dates and Army test data are the firm ground. The ZIL figures are the weakest: they come from Russian motoring press rather than a Soviet document, the accounts differ on engine power, and English-language articles quote other speeds and production counts.

What the record shows

Across more than 120 years of patents and prototypes, the screw has solved one problem repeatedly: carrying a load across surfaces too soft for wheels, such as marsh mud, floating weed and deep drifts. It has failed on the hard ground in between. Each program also met the same practical issue, how to carry the machine to its operating area, which is why the WES report devotes an appendix to trailers and why the ZIL-2906 rode to work on the back of a truck.

Sources